Exercises- Civilising the “Native”, Educating the Nation

Exercises- Civilising the “Native”, Educating the Nation Important Formulae

You are currently studying
Grade 8 → History → Civilising the “Native”, Educating the Nation → Exercises- Civilising the “Native”, Educating the Nation

Please see the numericals tab to see homework questions and solutions.

Match the following:



William Jones

Rabindranath Tagore 

Thomas Macaulay 

Mahatma Gandhi
Pathshalas



promotion of English education
respect for ancient cultures
gurus
learning in a natural environment

critical of English education

Solution:
William Jones - respect for ancient cultures
Rabindranath Tagore - learning in a natural environment
Thomas Macaulay - promotion of English education
Mahatma Gandhi - critical of English education
Pathshalas - gurus

State whether true or false
:

(a)  James Mill was a severe critic of the Orientalists. 

(b)  The 1854 Despatch on education was in favour 
English being introduced as a medium of higher education in India. 

(c)  Mahatma Gandhi thought that promotion of literacy was the most important aim of education. 

(d)  Rabindranath Tagore felt that children ought to be subjected to strict discipline.

Solution:
Here are the statements evaluated for truth or falsehood:

(a) James Mill was a severe critic of the Orientalists.
True. James Mill was critical of the Orientalists, especially their views on Indian culture and education. He advocated for the Westernization of India and believed that Indian civilization was inferior to Western civilization.

(b) The 1854 Despatch on education was in favour of English being introduced as a medium of higher education in India.
True. The 1854 Despatch, also known as the "Wood's Despatch," supported the introduction of English as the medium of instruction for higher education in India, as well as the establishment of universities in major cities.

(c) Mahatma Gandhi thought that promotion of literacy was the most important aim of education.
False. Mahatma Gandhi believed in education that focused on character development, self-reliance, and the practical application of skills, rather than just promoting literacy. He emphasized the importance of moral and ethical values in education.

(d) Rabindranath Tagore felt that children ought to be subjected to strict discipline.
False. Rabindranath Tagore believed in a more relaxed and creative approach to education. He opposed rigid discipline and instead advocated for an education system that nurtured creativity, freedom, and holistic development.

Why did William Jones feel the need to study Indian history, philosophy and law?

Solution:

William Jones, a British scholar, felt the need to study Indian history, philosophy, and law for several reasons. Firstly, he believed that the study of Indian culture would help in understanding the rich traditions and values of the Indian subcontinent, which were largely unknown to the British at the time. As a judge in the British East India Company, he recognized that understanding local customs and legal systems was crucial for administering justice effectively in India.

Jones was also fascinated by the intellectual achievements of ancient India. He admired the Indian contributions to fields like mathematics, astronomy, and philosophy, which he thought were highly advanced compared to those in the West. Additionally, he saw the study of Indian languages, particularly Sanskrit, as key to unlocking ancient texts and scriptures, which contained valuable knowledge about Indian society, law, and philosophy.

Jones believed that by studying these subjects, he could bridge the gap between the British and Indian cultures, promoting a better understanding between the two. He also hoped that this knowledge would help in the formulation of British policies in India, taking into account Indian traditions and legal practices.

Why did James Mill and Thomas Macaulay think that European education was essential in India?

Solution:

Why did James Mill and Thomas Macaulay think that European education was essential in India?

James Mill and Thomas Macaulay were influential figures during the British colonial rule in India. Both believed that European education was essential for the progress and development of India. Their arguments were based on the following reasons:

1. Introduction of Western knowledge: James Mill and Thomas Macaulay felt that European education, particularly Western science, literature, and philosophy, was superior to the traditional Indian knowledge system. They believed that India needed to adopt Western ideas to advance in various fields like science, technology, and governance.

2. Creation of a class of British officials: Both Mill and Macaulay argued that European education would help create a class of educated Indians who could assist the British government in administering India. This class would understand English and the Western ways of governance, thus making it easier for the British to control the country.

3. Elimination of traditional practices: Mill and Macaulay considered many of India's traditional practices to be backward and irrational. They believed that European education would replace these practices with rational and progressive ideas. This would help in the modernization of Indian society.

4. Promotion of British culture: Macaulay, in particular, believed that the British way of life, language, and culture were superior to the Indian traditions. He wanted to promote English as the medium of instruction in schools, which would, in turn, introduce Indian students to British literature and ideals, aligning them with the colonial power's values.

Thus, for Mill and Macaulay, European education was seen as a tool for both political control and cultural transformation in India.

Why did Mahatma Gandhi want to teach children handicrafts?

Solution:

Why did Mahatma Gandhi want to teach children handicrafts?

Mahatma Gandhi believed that teaching children handicrafts was important for several reasons:

  • He felt that it would help children become self-reliant by learning skills that could provide them with a means of livelihood.
  • Gandhi saw handicrafts as a way to connect children to their cultural heritage and traditional skills, promoting the value of manual work.
  • He believed that handicrafts would help children develop discipline, patience, and a sense of pride in their work.
  • Gandhi also thought that it would instill values of simplicity and self-sufficiency, encouraging children to value work over mere intellectual knowledge.
  • He hoped that teaching handicrafts could promote unity and social cohesion by engaging children in activities that would benefit their communities, particularly through rural development.

Why did Mahatma Gandhi think that English education had enslaved Indians?

Solution:

Why did Mahatma Gandhi think that English education had enslaved Indians?

Mahatma Gandhi believed that English education had enslaved Indians because it created a mental dependency on the British and distanced Indians from their own culture and heritage. He argued that the English education system was designed to produce a class of people who would serve the British rulers, often referred to as the "brown Englishmen." This system focused on Western knowledge, which made Indians feel inferior about their own traditions, languages, and values.

According to Gandhi, the education system promoted by the British created a sense of alienation from the Indian way of life, making Indians see their own culture as backward. He also criticized the fact that English education was not aimed at the masses but at creating a small elite class of people who could work for the British government. This, in Gandhi's view, was a form of intellectual and cultural enslavement.

Furthermore, Gandhi believed that the emphasis on English as a medium of instruction led to the neglect of native languages and knowledge. This not only weakened the Indian identity but also made Indians dependent on British rulers for knowledge and progress. Instead, Gandhi promoted a system of education that would connect the people with their own culture, knowledge, and rural development, which he thought would empower them and help them break free from colonial control.

Find out from your grandparents about what they studied in school.

Solution:

What My Grandparents Studied in School

When I asked my grandparents about what they studied in school, they shared their experiences of education during their childhood. They mentioned that their curriculum was quite different from what we have today. Most of the subjects they studied included basic reading, writing, and arithmetic, but there were also a few other subjects such as history, geography, and moral science.

My grandfather, who grew up in a rural area, said that the school had a focus on practical skills, such as learning how to work with hands and farming techniques. He studied subjects like mathematics, Hindi, and science, but there was no mention of modern subjects like computers or technology. His school did not have many resources, and the education was focused on basic skills for daily life.

My grandmother, who went to school in a more urban setting, recalled studying subjects like English, history, and geography. She said that the textbooks used during her time were quite old and often had limited illustrations. However, they still had to memorize a lot of information, especially in subjects like history. She mentioned that the education system was very formal, with teachers strictly following the textbooks and expecting students to learn by rote.

Overall, their education system was very different from the present, with less emphasis on technology, and more focus on practical life skills and memorization of lessons. It was also a time when fewer people had access to formal education, and the learning environment was shaped by the resources available in those times.

Find out about the history of your school or any other school in the area you live.

Solution:

History of the School

The history of our school begins with its foundation in [Year of Establishment]. It was established by [Founder Name] with the aim of providing quality education to children in the local community. Over the years, the school has grown from a small institution with only a few students to a large educational establishment with multiple facilities.

Initially, the school focused on offering basic education in subjects like English, Mathematics, and Science. However, as the years passed, the curriculum expanded to include subjects like History, Geography, and Arts. The school adopted modern teaching methods and infrastructure, keeping pace with educational trends.

In the early years, the school was housed in a small building with limited resources. As the demand for education increased, the school administration worked towards expanding the infrastructure. New classrooms, a library, science labs, and sports facilities were added. The school's commitment to all-round development of students led to the introduction of extracurricular activities such as music, dance, and drama.

In the [decade], the school experienced a major shift in its approach to teaching, with the introduction of technology in classrooms. Smartboards, projectors, and computer labs became an integral part of the learning experience. The school also started offering co-curricular programs to ensure that students excelled in both academic and non-academic fields.

The school has earned a good reputation over the years for its academic excellence, sports achievements, and cultural contributions. It continues to be a leading institution in the area, with a vision to provide quality education and shape the future of students.